“Oh God!” Kelly screamed as the first ridge of the dildo penetrated her and pushed itself into her asshole. The sensation itself was heavenly, but the intention of the invasion was not. Jayla was really letting her feel every bit of her loss and humiliation, going first with a slow, deep assfucking as the next ridges rubbed Kelly’s ring on the way inside. Kelly bit her lip to stop from shrieking in pleasure. God, she loved to be assfucked, as long as it was on her terms, which this little punishment session was most definitely not. Jayla, having reached bottom with the dildo, started to sway her hips faster, causing more glorious friction on Kelly’s rimhole and bring her to cry out again in orgasm, her 3rd of many for the day. As soon as Jayla realized she had caused Kelly to come, she immediately pulled the strap on out with a pop, causing Kelly to moan again. Striding in front of Kelly, she struck a provocative, dominant pose first, smirking at Kelly’s spread eagle, ass up position, knowing full well it could have been her right there.

“You don’t get to cum without me getting mine as well, loser,” she announced, turning around and sticking her butt right in Kelly’s face. Kelly’s eager tongue flicked out, licking around Jayla’s rosebud until with a grunt of satisfaction, Jayla thrust her ass backwards, causing Kelly’s tongue to slip between the muscles and a moan of pleasure to escape Jayla’s lips.

“Oooooh, that;s right, lick it, lick my asshole, get your tongue there and give it to me, you loser slut.” Kelly could only groan acceptance and continue rimming until Jayla came to orgasm thru a combination of dominance and anal sensation. Jayla collapsed momentarily, stunned that her victory had transformed all her nasty fantasies into reality. Kelly just lay there, waiting for the next degradation to be placed upon her, her brown hair curling sexily to the side. In sudden movement, Jayla rose and went over to her toybox, taking her present dildo out of the harness and putting on another one. Turning around, she smirked as she walked towards Kelly, her hips swaying and rolling with the motion of it it. Kelly, looking up was initially frightened, then suddenly aroused as she realized she was seeing a double forked dildo fastened around Jayla’s waist. Jayla strutted behind Kelly, slunk down to her knees slowly, further heightening the tension in the room. She spanked Kelly’s ass as soon as she wanted her in place, and Kelly obliged. Lining up both Kelly’s holes with the heads, Jayla gave a sudden thrust and slammed them both home. Kelly’s brown eyes widened in shock, and her mouth opened in a silent scream of both sudden pain and sensation coursed thru her. Flicking her long, black haired ponytail out of the way, Jayla grabbed hold of Kelly’s hips, and rocked them back and forth on the prongs buried deep in pussy and ass.

“Ugh, that;s right, egh, take it, ehgh, all of it, eugh, you useless, eugh, loser slut!” Jayla grunted, hammering both Kelly’s holes cruelly. Kelly could only moan thru a combination of agony and ecstasy. Jayla released her hold on Kelly’s hips and grabbed instead grabbed a hold of her hands, pulling them back and forcing Kelly’s head down to the ground where it rubbed back and forth painfully on the carpet. Jayla continued to slam the dildos in and out for a few minutes before decided she’d had enough and pushed Kelly’s defeated ass forward where it collapsed, her moan inaudible as her invaded ass and stretched pussy shrunk back to normal size. Jayla strutted to Kelly’s head while pulling off the strapon, grabbing Kelly’s hair when she reached it and yanking her onto her back. Kelly flopped to comply, arms and legs limply falling into place spread eagle. Only her eyes showed much sign of life as she watched her tormentor hovering over her, leering down at her defeated face and knowing only what was coming next was going to be humiliating. Jayla didn’t disappoint, as she strode over Kelly and sat directly over her face, her pussy an inch away from Kelly’s lips. Taking her finger, she spread her pussylips wide, and smiled cruelly. Kelly’s eyes flew wide as she realized what Jayla had in store for her, and while disgusted, she idly realized that had the positions been reversed, she would have done the same thing. 
“Open your mouth slut, and receive what you deserve” Jayla ordered as she let loose a golden shower of piss into Kelly’s mouth, in her defeated state, Kelly could only comply.

Kelly and Jayla first met Frosh year in HS as friends, and later enemies. Soph year Kelly dated the top jock, then junior year Jayla did. Their single mothers became acquaintances as well, so when they both decided to run PTA, Kelly and Jayla spent a lot of time together. After the beginning of their feud, they still met while their mothers were at PTA, usually just doing homework. On that fateful day, however, they didn’t have any, so they just lounged around in their uniforms, knee high sock, pleated skirts and blouses. Being bored and naturally horny 18 years olds, they sniped at each other over the only subject they had in common, namely Ryan the top jock. Jayla had heard Kelly couldn’t handle all of him, while Kelly had heard thru the rumor mill that Jayla had liked it anally. Calling each other sluts, whores, and various other creative names, they decided to settle it with an old-fashioned duel. Given the nature of their accusations was sexual, their creative minds settled on a dildo duel, first to cum loses. Grabbing 2 identical ones of Kelly’s mom’s, they went to the master bedroom to sort it out. Standing on opposite sides of the bed, they stood, dildos in hand, then simultaneously both peeled off their blouses, exposing their identical 34C chests. Next, they slid their thongs down underneath their skirts, appearing before each other topless and panty less underneath their skirts while still keeping their knee high socks on. Kelly openly checked out Jayla’s body and compared it to her own, bringing one of her hands up to tweak one of her pink nipples hard and the other bringing the dildo to her lips, sucking it lightly. A slight smile distorted her lips around the plastic dick as she saw Jayla do the same, tweaking her brown nipples the same and licking the fake cock to make it extra slippery.

“Rules?” Jayla fairly spat out. Kelly considered it for a second, then replied “No rules, first to squirt cum loses, and since we both know we do, there’s no mistaking it.” Indeed, one of the things they had learned from having a mutual boyfriend was they were both squirters, and messy ones at that. “No defense, no break, just you, me, and your defeat at my hands and this,” she replied coolly, shaking the dildo Jayla’s way and gripping it like a knife, all while smiling sweetly. Jayla replied with a smile, moved onto the bed sitting up on her knees, stopping once she reached the center of the bed and, hiking up her skirt till it barely covered her youthful lips, made a come hither gesture to Kelly, who reciprocated and obliged rapidly. Situated in front of their rival, they looked deep in the others eyes, looking for any sort of mental weakness, and finding none. Their bodies inched closer to each other, until their nipples lightly touched, sending a shudder thru both their bodies. As one, they positioned the dildos outside the entrance to each other’s snatch, stopped, waiting for a mutual signal.

“Ready?” Kelly said in a hoarse whisper. Jayla could only nod slightly, licking her lips. “Then lets fuck,” she said, punctuating the statement with a full French kiss on Jayla’s mouth and stabbing the dildo into her foe’s pussy simultaneously. Jayla’s eyes widened momentarily, but she responded quickly, banging her own dildo home into Kelly’s moist hole and causing a moan to be shared in their mutual kiss. The two school girl’s lips formed a tight seal while inside their tongues waged a battle of their own, wrestling and trying to penetrate each other’s mouth deeper than their own. Their left hands gripped the opposite buttcheek of their rivals, holding them and themselves steady while their right hands were a blur, pumping the dildos in and out of their enemy’s snatch. In short order, both of the girls began to drip precum juice onto the clenched hands of their rival, lubing up their holes and allowing a glorious friction to develop. Their inner thighs soon became wet and glistened softly in the light. They broke their kiss, each gasping for breath and instead rested their head on the other’s shoulder, drawing on all their youth and stamina to try and outlast the other. 

After about 10 mins of doing unto their rival’s pussy, Jayla began to feel the familiar feeling of an explosive orgasm building within her. Knowing she had to either hold out or escalate the fight, she shifted her hand from Kelly’s hip back to her rival’s asshole. Kelly’s eyes widened as she felt the intrusion, then threw her head back with a yowl as Jayla’s middle finger first penetrated her brown ring.
“Oh, you nasty bitch!” she cried, as Jayla’s finger slid further in. Not to be outdone, Kelly quickly shifted her own left hand to Jayla’s butt and roughly thrust 2 fingers into her rival’s own asshole. Jayla’s back stiffened as her ass was violated. She groaned as Kelly’s fingers slid into a V and proceeded in and out, exposing inner skin folds to the air and heightening the sensation. Jayla gritted her teeth and concentrated on Kelly’s ass and leaving the dildo embedded in her cunt, moved her other hand to Kelly’s now prominent clit. She delicately stroked Kelly’s clit while at the same time increased the rythym in her ass. Kelly just groaned and buried her head on Jayla’s shoulder while desperately trying to increase her own rhythm as well. It was a contest of endurance now, with the prize being the complete humiliation of the other at the hands of her rival. Five, 10, fifteen minutes there fingers slid in and out simultaneously, getting progressively stickier, until, at last sensing an opening, Jayla’s mouth moved like a snake and dropped down to Kelly’s nipple and started desperately sucking for all she was worth.

“Oh, you cheating, bitcccccchhhhhhhhhooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhh, ugh!” moaned Kelly as she went off at that point. Her hips started convulsing rhythmically, out of conscious control, and her cum sprayed out of her pussy, soaking Jayla’s hand and splattering all over the sheet. Jayla only smiled around her mouthful of tit and continued to suckle Kelly’s nipple, relishing its rigidity and extension in her mouth. After what seemed like minutes although it was only a matter of seconds, Kelly collapsed backwards, exhausted, her limps askew on the sheet, her eyes unfocused from the intensity of her orgasm.
 
Haughtily, arrogantly, Jayla crawled up over Kelly’s body and proceeded to violate her mouth with Jayla’s own tongue, making her feel every questing probe down to her tonsils. Positioning her knees over Kelly’s upper arms, she broke off her kiss suddenly and sat up, thrusting her bald snatch towards Kelly’s mouth. “My turn to cum, so eat me, loser!” she cried harshly, pulling Kelly’s head up to her crotch by the hair. Kelly, moaning with delicious humiliation, played her tongue across Jayla’s delicious cunt lips, still drenched with pre cum, then turned her quest south, licking and sucking around Jayla’s hole. Jayla moaned with pleasure, heightened by her dominant treatment of Kelly. In short order, Jayla’s hips began to buck and rock, signaling the beginning of her orgasm. Reaching behind her to grab a handful of Kelly’s breast and grabbing a handful of her own, she let out a shriek as she spurted like a geyser, drenching Kelly’s face and almost choking her. Coming down, her head righting itself, she looked down at her defeated foe, in as helpless a position as she could have imagined it. Smiling evilly, she scooted down Kelly’s body, taking off her foe’s skirt in the process, until she sat right on her stomach. Gauging the distance, she began slapped Kelly’s face and tits until all were red and sore.

“Who’s the best here, Kelly?” she asked, slapping her face as punctuation. When there was no response, she started to pinch one of her nipples, causing Kelly to shriek. “Who’s the better woman?” she asked again. 

“You are” Kelly whimpered, cringing. 

Jayla sat back, basking in the sensation of triumph. “Why am I better that you?” she demanded, wanting to hear it from Kelly’s own lips.

“Because your pussy is stronger than mine, you beat my pussy, oh god, please, you’re stronger, ooooh, let me go, please!” Kelly shrieked as Jayla shoved 2 fingers into her defeated ass. Jayla smiled with delight, knowing that she could do any twisted thing her mind had envisioned ever since she had stolen Ryan junior year. Getting up, she stripped off her skirt, went to the closet and got out her favorite anal strap on, ridged to heighten sensation and long to penetrate to untold depths. She slipped the harness snugly onto her hips and came back over to Kelly, dragging her onto the floor onto her stomach in the face down, ass up position. Smiling cruelly, she pulled her long black hair back into a ponytail and then positioned herself and the dildo at the entrance of Kelly’s now reddened ass. Gripping Kelly’s hips, she leaned down and whispered into her ear.

“As soon as I’m tired of you, I’m going to call Ryan over, and let him have you anyway he wants. This is only beginning, bitch,” Kelly could only groan as the dildo inched towards her ass, the heavenly nightmare had begun…